Skip to Content
Methvin Home
Case Study · Commercial Estimating

How Universal Constructions won a tender on a Connected commercial workflow

A subcontract-driven civil and building contractor tested Methvin directly against its established Excel process on a live tender, then used the platform to win the project and shape Methvin’s product roadmap.

UC Tender WorkspaceACTIVE
Subcontract Tender & Adjudication
Universal Constructions · Client: Confidential
EstimatingTender BoQ
AdjudicationSubcontractor pricing
Job CostingRated & client BoQ
SettingsTrade structures
Original tender BoQ100%
Subcontractor adjudication100%
Rated & client BoQIn progress

A live tender, tested against Excel

Universal Constructions ran a high-volume tender operation on multiple concurrent bids. A typical bid required building a detailed BoQ, pricing internal resources, adjudicating subcontractors, and producing rated and client-ready versions of the same commercial data.

Historically that workflow produced multiple copies of the same information, maintained separately across every stage of adjudication and negotiation.

UC tested Methvin directly against its established Excel process on a live tender. Methvin’s version was awarded the project, and the estimating team’s workflow-level feedback went straight into the product roadmap.

Company Profile · Universal Constructions

IndustrySubcontract-driven civil & building construction
LeadershipMatthew Carr, Managing Director
ActivityHigh-volume tender operation, multiple concurrent bids
Core WorkflowEstimating → Subcontractor Adjudication → BoQ Management
Delivery ModelSubcontract tendering and award
SoftwareMethvin
Project Overview

Moving beyond disconnected spreadsheets

UC's tendering process runs on more than producing a single price. A typical bid requires building a detailed BoQ, pricing internal resources, adjudicating subcontractors, and producing rated and client-ready versions of the same commercial data.

Industry
Civil & building construction
Leadership
Matthew Carr, MD
Activity
High-volume concurrent tenders
Workflow
Estimate → Adjudicate → BoQ
Delivery
Subcontract tendering and award
Client
Confidential
Building and managing a detailed tender Bill of Quantities
Working with internal resources and rates
Breaking work into relevant trades and packages
Requesting and receiving subcontractor pricing
Comparing subcontractor prices against internal expectations
Negotiating final rates and managing margin
Producing a final rated version for internal use
Producing a client-ready version with gross rates
The Challenge

Version control at the heart of the commercial process

Historically, this workflow produced multiple copies of the same information, maintained separately across every stage of adjudication and negotiation.

Three BoQs, maintained by hand

An original tender BoQ, a rated BoQ carrying final negotiated rates, and a separate client-facing gross-rate version were each maintained by hand, with various interim versions produced during adjudication and negotiation.

Risk a subcontract-driven business can’t afford

This created version control risk, duplicate data entry, and limited visibility across the commercial workflow — exactly the kind of exposure a subcontract-driven business can’t afford heading into a busy tender period.
Software Used

Modules deployed across the commercial workflow

UC's engagement centres on the parts of Methvin that carry a tender from first price to client handover.

Estimating

  • Tender BoQ import and management
  • Internal resources and rate libraries
  • Trade and package breakdown
  • Rated and client-ready BoQ output

Adjudication

  • Subcontractor package creation
  • Internal baseline pricing
  • Quote comparison and negotiation
  • Commercial trail through to final rate

Settings & Configuration

  • Custom trade structures
  • Dissection code alignment
  • Administrator-managed setup
  • Configured to UC's own methodology
Workflow Transformation

Before Methvin vs After Methvin

AreaBefore MethvinAfter Methvin
BoQ VersionsSeparate Tender, rated and client BoQs maintained by hand across spreadsheetsConnected One dataset carried through tender, rated and client views
AdjudicationManual Subcontractor pricing compared by hand against internal expectationsStructured Packages, baseline pricing and comparison managed in one workspace
Trade StructureReconciled UC's dissection codes matched manually against a generic structureConfigurable Trades managed directly through Settings to match UC's own codes
Performance120s Full recalculation on a large dataset took up to 120 seconds15x faster Same-scale recalculation completed in 8 seconds

What a connected commercial workflow delivered

What working directly with Methvin's product and engineering teams delivered on a live, subcontract-driven tender operation.

  • Live tender priced in both Excel and Methvin, with Methvin's version awarded the project
  • Full recalculation cut from 120 seconds to 8 seconds on a 35,000 bill item / 60,000 worksheet item dataset
  • Server infrastructure upgraded ahead of a four-tender month, including a migration to Redis caching
  • Adjudication workflow enhancement scoped directly with UC via a live walkthrough
  • Internal baseline pricing paths mapped ahead of subcontractor quotes arriving
  • Trade structures configurable to UC's own dissection codes
  • Same-evening support response securing UC's BoQ structure on a live award
15x
Faster full recalculation on a 35k/60k item dataset
50,000+
Line items tested under sustained, live-tender load
5 min
Support response on a live commercial award decision
3
Workflow enhancements scoped directly from UC's feedback
ROI Analysis

Where the value shows up

Version control risk and recalculation speed sit directly on the critical path of a subcontract-driven tender operation.

Value DriverBasisEstimated Annual Value
Recalculation performanceFull recalculation on a 35,000 bill item / 60,000 worksheet item dataset120s → 8s (15x faster)
Infrastructure scalingRedis caching migration and capacity increase ahead of a four-tender monthSustained performance through peak load
Version controlTender, rated and client BoQs carried from one dataset instead of maintained separatelyReduced duplicate entry and version risk
Support responsivenessSame-evening guidance on structuring a BoQ following a live award5-minute response, immediate live call
OverallFaster, lower-risk commercial turnaround
15x
Faster recalculation
50,000+
Line items under live load
5 min
Support response on award
Client Perspective

In their own words

We see Methvin not as an off-the-shelf tool, but as a platform we help shape.

MC
Matthew Carr
Managing Director · Universal Constructions
Lessons Learned

What made the evaluation work

  • Testing Methvin directly against a live, Excel-run tender gave UC a genuine before/after comparison rather than a demo-based evaluation.
  • Feeding workflow-level feedback, not just bug reports, to the product team shaped real roadmap decisions within the same cycle.
  • Establishing an internal pricing baseline before subcontractor quotes arrive keeps adjudication commercially grounded from the outset.
  • Configuring trade structures to match existing dissection codes reduces friction rather than forcing a new coding system onto the business.
  • Performance headroom matters most heading into concentrated tender periods, not only in steady-state use.
Future Plans

What UC is taking forward

  • Develop the awarded, dual-tendered project into a full UC/client-ready BoQ within Methvin.
  • Adopt the dedicated adjudication tab once released, keeping packages open alongside resources.
  • Apply the internal baseline pricing workflow on upcoming adjudications ahead of subcontractor quotes.
  • Configure trade structures against UC's dissection codes as further tenders move onto the platform.

Key Takeaways

Real-world validation: Methvin tested against an established Excel workflow on a live, awarded tender.
One dataset carried through tender, rated and client BoQ views instead of three separately maintained versions.
Proactive infrastructure delivery: a 15x recalculation improvement shipped ahead of UC's busiest tender month.
Direct feedback channel between UC's estimating leadership and Methvin's development team.
Multiple product enhancements scoped and tracked from UC's real-world workflow needs.
Same-evening, five-minute support turnaround on a live commercial award decision.

Bring your tender workflow onto one connected platform

Whether you are pricing a subcontract package or running a high-volume tender desk, Methvin connects estimating, adjudication and BoQ output from first price through to client handover.

Global support · Dedicated onboarding · Cancel anytime